Make Way For Tomorrow & The Awful Truth

Make Way For Tomorrow and The Awful Truth
In the year 1937, Leo McCarey directed two films. One flopped and disappeared for seventy years. The other won him the Academy Award for Best Director. When receiving the Oscar, he said “Thanks but you’ve given it to me for the wrong film…” This double-header was a chance to see both films together and the cinema club audience unanimously agreed with McCarey; that while ‘The Awful Truth’ may be an entertaining comedy, it is ‘Make Way For Tomorrow’ that is the masterpiece! A film
about an elderly couple was never destined to do well at the box office, however, its power should not be underestimated, because by the time the last frame melts away, don’t be surprised if you feel like your heart has just been wrenched out of your body. It is a traumatic film, and yet a rich one, with vivid characters, pulsating with honest beauty. What does one do with the elderly when there is nowhere for them to go? What do their children do and at what cost? The film holds up a mirror to all those watching it where, although we may feel disgust at the behaviour of the grown-up children of the elderly couple, we also feel discomfort at the fact that we understand the children and even may identify with them. The film challenges us in a way that demands a response. It is a difficult challenge, one that most would prefer to ignore, but one that invites us to look into ourselves and what we believe in to hazard an answer.
The Awful Truth appears like fluff after such an experience, but this fluff won McCarey THE Academy Award. And it is rather impressive that a screwball comedy could affirm marriage through its depiction of the lead characters’ ‘divorce’. Witty, elegant, romantic, and funny, this seems the perfect definition for what “comedy” should be. Leo McCarey was a practicing Catholic who would later give us films like “Going My Way” and “An Affair to Remember,” but in these two films of 1937, we already see a master at telling great stories, be they comedy or tragedy, yet in both the ability to reflect themes crucial to building a culture of life.
Warning: The reflections below are full of spoilers. The aim is to share these insights with all who are inspired to watch these films and help to draw out even more from the experience. So watch the films first and read the reflections afterwards…
IN THIS POST
*Marriage in McCarey by Pablo Vila
*A Reflection on ‘Make Way For Tomorrow’ by Benard Chedid
Continue reading →